![]() |
|
Ralph Potter and Sam McKinney
hold petitions with 4,250 names in their drive for a referendum. (Ron
Campbell / Johnson City Press) |
While plenty of people have had their say on what good or harm their referendum would cause the county and the city of Elizabethton, the two men have not said much about why they spent so much time and effort to obtain 4,250 signatures.
“Our basic thing was to get accountability in local government,” Potter said. He said he was frustrated when he tried to find out where tax money was being spent in the county. “What we need is a spreadsheet that shows where the money came in today and where it went out. Each day. Then we will know where our money is being spent.”
Potter said the taxpayers are paying the bills, but government officials are not answering to the taxpayers. “This is where the people can step in and say ‘enough is enough’ ” McKinney said.
The two men started thinking about the issue after a wheel tax referendum failed in the county. They wondered why the voters had always been asked to vote on referendums that raised taxes, but never on a referendum that lowered taxes.
As far as they know, Potter and McKinney are exploring new ground in the state. Potter said there have been lots of statements of gloom and doom if their referendum passes, with politicians saying it would ruin the schools, to budget officials saying it would mean a 65-cent increase in the property tax rate for the county.
“They can’t even pass a 44-cent increase, so I don’t see how they can pass a 65-cent increase,” Potter said, referring to the county’s difficulty in passing a budget.
Most of the criticism of the proposed referendum centers on the impact the tax cut would have on the school system. Potter and McKinney agree the tax cut would cause drastic changes for the schools, but they believe that could be a good thing.
“We are not trying to kill the school system, we just want accountability,” McKinney said. “There are school systems all over the U.S. that are too political,” Potter said.
Despite President Bush’s No Child Left Behind initiative, he said it is still a matter of where a child comes from that determines the quality of education received. As an example, they point to the Carter County School Board’s decision to build a new high school in Stoney Creek.
Potter said Unaka is no older than Happy Valley or Cloudland. He estimated the cost of replacing all these high schools at $100 million when Elizabethton’s share of bond receipts is figured in.
Based on the number of students, Potter said the county has too many teachers. “We need to consolidate,” Potter said. “We need to go up to Rittertown somewhere and build one school for the whole county. It is nice to have neighborhood schools, but we can’t afford it.”
“If we can get rid of all the bad teachers, there should be enough money left to give raises to the good teachers,” McKinney said.
While there has been plenty of talk about how bad the loss of revenue would be for the city and county, Potter and McKinney say no one really knows what will happen if the referendum passes.
“I don’t know what will happen,” Potter said. “This has never been done before in the state. Never have the people in Carter County had the chance to lower their own taxes.”
Potter and McKinney are awaiting the results from the Election Commission. They turned in 4,250 signatures. As of Monday afternoon, the commission staff has counted 2,150 good signatures, but the petition must have 3,016 good signatures to qualify.
The two Roan Mountain men said they would not be too upset if the petition fails to have enough registered voters.
“This was a shot across the bow,” Potter said. “We got their attention.”
County Finance Director Jason Cody said he understands how Potter and McKinney got so many people to sign the petition, but he wonders how many would be willing to see county services cut so deeply.
“I understand people want lower taxes, but this will have an impact on every area of the county — there will be less patrols by the sheriff’s department, doing away with many programs in the schools, such as the extracurricular activities. Whenever I hear from the community, they are always wanting more services, not less.”